Score: 4

"not there yet my fren"

submission: Rival Part 2: Escape

date: May 22, 2003

the animation is not good enough. camera angles are not suitable... some are ok.. just ok... the graphics, u have ur style which is a slightly better than a stick figure cos it has a face but that's just not good graphic... i'll give a ten if u come up with detailed high end graphics. there's no style to it. sound sucks... compose ur own song. or at least choose something unrecogniseable so that ppl do not compare. learn ur cinematography, boy.

Score: 10

"Right Emotions"

submission: "From my Room"

date: March 17, 2002

Thoughtful flash, i like it very much! and a good msg...wonderfully animated...

Score: 8

"Ur Da Man"

submission: HERE

date: February 28, 2002

Well, great job there! Nice relaxing music...and i think the other reviewers should give some points for the interactivity since we get to choose music while loading and at the ending.... it's still interactive...

Score: 6

"not bad"

submission: smart stick adventure!

date: February 24, 2002

graphics should improve. sound is okay, cheered me up but didn't loop well. completely interactive. nice idea, good job for keeping the file size down. and if u can only improve on ur grpahics, u'll get 2 thumbs up from me... seriously. but now, one thumbs up!

Score: 7

"Not Bad"

submission: Do You Remember Macross?

date: February 23, 2002

i notice alot of u guys praising him for the drawings... letme tell u the truth.. he modeled it in a 3d program like he said in his comments and the computer calculated the rest of the animation for him.... he did not draw it frame by frame especially when the transformation scene plays... but it's still a great technic... just want to let u guys know the real way it was done... i myself major in 3d animation and i'm using Softimage|XSI v1.5

Score: 5

"Not Bad"

submission: Greenday Video-The grouch

date: February 11, 2002

Just need lotsa improvements on grpahics.... plus, learn how to make a preloader.... and... make it stop at the end and give an option to the viewer wether to replay or not instead of looping the whole animation

Score: 4

"Thief?"

submission: offspring music vid(ff9)

date: February 11, 2002

i read the rest of the reviews and found out this wasn't ur original work.... what a loser... my work have been stolen once and been published here... and i know the feeling of it... so u deserve a vote for an X!

Score: 3

"This is what i hafta say"

submission: PapaRoAcH

date: February 10, 2002

it's basically all words words and words.... no cartoon animation at all.... graphics... din score much cos used only fonts mostly... sound wise, nice song... but should make a cencored version along with it.... no interactivity at all... style sux... voilence as in song lyrics,.... not funny.... overall, 3/10....thanx keep it up tho... and yeah... learn how to make a preloader.....

Score: 2

"This needs lots of improvement"

submission: Linkin Park Music Video 1

date: February 10, 2002

your graphics need LOTS of improvement. I gave 10 for sound cos LP deserves it not u. there was no interactivity. style awefully sux. kinda violence there but some ppl like it. 10 points for humor cos ur graphics kinda made me laugh off my seat.. not the movie quality... overall, u have to improve on ur graphics, timing, and be more creative.... that's all i gt say....peace